COMMENTS GALORE ... 56

COMMENTS GALORE ... 56

Sugata Bose @Sanjeev Shrivastava : Lovely gibberish---a religious response.

Sugata Bose @Rupa Ganguli : Cowardice at this hour when the need is to resist the progressive Islamisation of West Bengal whose criminal output we are witnessing in many a district in the state cannot be condoned. Today, valour must be deemed virtue and not idle posting like this or pretentious piety or even real passive piety. Ramakrishna Mission, Jalpaiguri in its Siliguri 'Sevak House' was under terrible armed attack where mayhem was conducted at gunpoint followed by kidnapping of the monks and the lay workers in the dead of night before releasing them near New Jalpaiguri Station. When the Mission is thus facing an existential threat, how can its initiated devotees be content with exhibiting such passive piety that would put their credentials as devotees to shame? Resist like the brave Lakshmibai, Durgavati, Nivedita, Rashmoni and the Ranis of the Rani Jhansi Regiment of the INA. 🕉 Hindu today is the solidarity call.

Sugata Bose @Sameer Banik : Never. In no way. Hinduism is based on the Atman which is spirit and not matter which secularism is all about. Separation of state power from religion is as well the foundation of secularism which is contradisposed to Hinduism in which state power is wielded strictly in accordance with the dharma.

Sugata Bose @হিন্দু মুসলমানের মধ্যে পর্বতপ্রমাণ ব্যবধানের কারণ শাস্ত্রগত মূল পার্থক্য | সনাতন শাত্র (বেদবেদান্ত) সর্বগ্রাসী কিন্তু ইসলামীয় শাস্ত্র (কোরান, হাদীস, সিরা) একদেশদর্শী | ইসলাম মানবজগতকে দার-উল-হার্ব ও দার-উল-ইসলাম এ বিভাজিত করে; সনাতন ধর্ম সমস্ত জগৎপ্রপঞ্চকে ব্রহ্মের প্রকাশরূপে একীভূত দেখে | ইসলাম বিধ্বংসী | অন্য ধর্মকে সহ্য করতে পারে না | ভিন্ন ধর্মাবলম্বীকে দমন, ধর্মান্ততরীত অথবা হত্যা করার বিধান দেয় | সনাতন ধর্ম সকলকে ঈশ্বরপ্রতীমরূপে পূজা করে | আকাশপাতাল প্রভেদ | তাই একপাক্ষিক প্রেম বন্টনে হিন্দুর সর্বনাশ সাধিত হয়েছে, হবে | বাস্তববাদিতার অভাব অধর্ম | এই সব পার্থক্যগুলো মাথায় রেখে স্বধর্ম পালন ও রক্ষা করতে হবে | নইলে পরিণাম ভয়বহ | 🕉 হিন্দু!

Sugata Bose @Swami Shivapremananda : The monks (Bharat Sevashram Sangha) are virile but the music accompanying the tāndav (sword dance) rather effeminate. This must not be.

Sugata Bose @Alok Sarkar : You are extremely arrogant, self-conceited beyond reasonable measure. This was a polite question which did not merit such a rude response.

Sugata Bose @Saumitra Basu : ওই আনন্দেই থাকুন | এই কথাই ১৯৩০ এর দশকে হিন্দুরা বলতেন | '৪৭এ ভীষণ রক্তরঞ্জিত দেশভাগ ! আজ আবার সেই পুরোনো কথা | স্মৃতি কী সামান্য ! বিনাশ আগতপ্রায় অথচ চৈতন্য নেই, শত্রুবোধও নেই | কাপুরুষতার আর এক নাম বিস্মরণ | 🕉 হিন্দু !

Sugata Bose @Saumitra Basu : Your observation, though, has merit. We must end our petty squabbles and unite against all our civilisational enemies. That is the Vedic exhortation of the Rishis as well on us.🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Tanmoy Lodh : To awaken sleeping souls like you to the dangers of progressive Islamisation of West Bengal and India. We cannot allow a second Kashmir here or a recurrence of pre-Partition horrors such as the Great Calcutta Killing of 16 August, 1946 and the subsequent massive genocide of Hindus in Noakhali in especial but everywhere in East Bengal in general, the molestation of our women and the forced conversion of the Hindus to Islam. What followed thereafter during Partition and further on in East Pakistan culminating in the disproportionate Hindu genocide by West Pakistani forces in alliance with East Pakistani Razakars is well chronicled in history. Then followed the progressive Islamisation of 'secular' Bangladesh and the continued persecution of Hindus, Buddhists, Christians and protesting rationalists there which has led to yearly exodus of Hindus from Bangladesh ever since reducing its population from 27% in 1971 at the time of Liberation to a bare 8% today. As Hindus are getting weeded out by Islamists in Bangladesh, Muslims through immigration and high fertility of women are on the rise here with the Communists from 1967 to 1969, the Congress from 1972 to 1977, the Communists again from 1977 to 2011 and now the TMC from 2011 till date patronising their growth in numbers through immigration and the building of Islamic infrastructure through ever-increasing number of mosques and madrāsās, with the ruling dispensation doing it the most to keep its minority vote-bank steady and its electoral invincibility going. This situation is unacceptable to all patriotic souls steeped in the Sanatan civilisation. Thus, it is imperative that wakeful souls keep sounding the gong that sleeping souls may awake. 🕉 Hindu !

Sugata Bose @Tanmoy Lodh : Your question is malicious and not naive or innocent in any way. The words 'real motive' read into your mind well enough to return you a sharper retort than you have received here. Earlier you went on making extraneous comments on the Electoral Bond in posts totally unrelated to it. Now you make this veiled charge in the mode of a question of myself having ulterior motives in making my posts related to the Islamic problem. Moreover, as in the past, you lack the civility to acknowledge my answer, especially a detailed one at that by way of my response to your query. You have earlier cracked a joke on my age as well which was rather discourteous. Now, son, be not under the delusion that I cannot read into your motives and am naive enough to see good intent in your slanted observations and utterly extraneous questions that in truth merit no answer. Either be civil and continue discourse along courteous lines or face my indifference or ire hereon. I do not appreciate people making slanted observations on me. Such comments will draw my ire and a volley of words which surely will not transgress Parliamentary linguistic civility but may for their intensity be quite unpalatable. Hence, be cautioned and do not make unseemly remarks on my self or my motivations. It were better if you saved such scrutiny on your esteemed self instead. May sense and sanity prevail ! May Mother bless you for you are in the bloom of youth and may make much of such benediction in furthering the cause of civilisation your way ! 🕉 Hindu !

Sugata Bose @Tanmoy Lodh : Thank you for responding and showing your concern for the country your way. May Mother guide you towards a worthy goal! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Ashok Chakraborty : সব বলব আমি ? অনেক কথা বলতে হয় তাহলে | ভেবে নিন নিজে |

Sugata Bose @Kaushik R Ray : O yes, and very concerned as well. Some people give this 'anger' sign to protest against the post. Hence, wanted to sound you out lest you be so as well. I am relieved that you are not so but are disturbed as well by the growing Islamisation of this state which has borne much Islamic tyranny historically. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Sameer Banik : It is already happening. The Ex-Muslim Movement is rapidly eroding the base of Islam and aiding apostasisation of Muslims by the masses, although, out of fear the apostates are mostly under cover. The boom in subcontinental Muslim population over the next few decades is as per the predictions made by PEW RESEARCH, an American data analysis and assessment organisation. The facts are as well clear to any sufficiently aware individual from everyday experience and online exposure today. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Kaushik R Ray : You have understood it right that the Qur'an ought to be at any rate read to understand our civilisational danger. Unfortunately, others don't. They pretend a lot even as they beat about the bush in their sermons on the Sanatan scriptures.

Sugata Bose @Sanjib Das : Not of much consequence in India where preparations for Ghazwa-e-Hind is afoot.

Sugata Bose @Debaprasad Bhattacharya : Mere hope will not realise cherished objectives. We have to work for it full-steam like the ex-Muslims are doing risking their lives. Courage, courage to die for the sustenance of the Dharma is the call of the hour. What are a few shlokas memorised and recited if they cannot in the battlefield of life be duly executed? The Bhagavadgeeta calls out for Arjuns and not for song and dance effeminates or passive priests uttering peace chants. It is as much a philosophical treatise as it is a war manual uttered by the prince of Avatars, Krishna, early in our civilisation to facilitate the then and all future defence of the Dharma. Courage, I reiterate, is the call of the hour, and that is renunciation, the renunciation of fear. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Tirtha Ghosh : তা, গান্ধীজী চালু করলেই বা কি ? আমরা তো তা পালন নাও করতে পারি | আপনি, আমি যদি ইসলামের সত্যাসত্য যথাযথভাবে জনসমক্ষে তুলে ধরি তো আর গোল বাঁধে না আমাদের জীবনে | সে দৃষ্টান্ত দেখে অন্যরাও শিখবেন | কি বলেন ?

Sugata Bose @Dhananjoy Chakraborty : Please unfriend me or unfollow me or block me so that you are spared the pain of seeing my 'phaltu posts'. And if you are too lazy or otherwise disinclined to do so, then bear these 'phaltu posts' like an anti-Modi yogi (not Yogi Adityanath who must be equally on your dislike list) or intimate me kindly whether I shall relieve you of your pain by unfriending you. Awaiting your Highness' reply. 🕉 Hindu!

P.S. Kindly intimate me as well what sort of posts would humour your ego, that is, would be to your liking. Must I be a bondman to your wishes?

Sugata Bose @Abhisekhar Majumdar : প্রেম দিতে পারেন নিত্যানন্দ প্রভু, আপনি নন | প্রেমাবস্থা মহাভাব যা সমাধিলাভের পরেই সম্ভব, তাও আধিকারিক আধারে, সামান্যে নয় | নিছক রসিকতার বস্তু বৈষ্ণব তত্ত্ব নয় | গভীরতা চাই, চাই পূর্ণ ইন্দ্রিয়সংযম | এ সব বাঙালীর লঘুচিত্ত বাক্যবিন্যাসের বস্তু নয়, অধ্যাত্ম শিখরে অবস্থিত মহামানবের হৃদয়োৎসারিত মহাবাক্য যা ঊর্ধ্বচৈতন্যে অবস্থানপূর্বক বোধের বিষয়, ভোগাশ্রয়ী মানবের রহস্যালাপের সামান্যবস্তু নয় | ঠাকুরের ভাষায়, "প্যাম প্যাম যে কর গা, প্যাম কি সহজ কথা গা ? প্যাম এলে জগত ভুল হয়ে যায় | নিজের দেহ যে এত প্রিয়, তাও খেয়াল থাকে না |" স্বামীজী বলেছেন, "God is love, and love is God. And God is everywhere. After seeing that God is love and God is everywhere, one does not know whether one stands on one's head or [on one's] feet — like a man who gets a bottle of wine and does not know where he stands. . . . If we weep ten minutes for God, we will not know where we are for the next two months. . . . We will not remember the times for meals. We will not know what we are eating. [How can] you love God and always be so nice and businesslike? . . . The . . . all-conquering, omnipotent power of love — how can it come? . . ." অতএব, আমি বিরত রইলাম এরপর আর কথা বাড়ানোয় |

Sugata Bose @Pkc Chowdhuree : Islamic fundamental ideology broke the nation. Read the Islamic scriptural trinity of the Qur'an, the Hadees and the Sira, and you will discover the real reason. Then Gandhiji will stand absolved of the sin.

Sugata Bose @Nilanjana Chakraborty : The dead do not speak. Since you are still doing so, you still have a chance to revive and serve.

Sugata Bose @Arun Sengupta : Absolutely so. Apolitical apology has gone on far too long, gone far too far.

Sugata Bose @Анандамой Мухопадхяй : That unfortunately is the case and that signifies both cowardice and villainy. Instead of lionising the valorous warriors for the cause, the latter are sacrificed at the altar of service to the motherland by cowardly crooks, perfidious betrayers who know nothing better than lowly self-interest as worthy goals to achieve.

Sugata Bose @Sudipto Chakraborty : I agree. I only hope you have not mistaken me to be my namesake, Sarat Bose's grandson, which would be rather routinely unfortunate for me, afflicted as I am by this constant misidentification for which I take no pride naturally, being proud of my actual lineage elsewhere where I duly belong. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Chandradeb Mukhopadhyay : Why? To be a conscientious Hindu, is it not enough to be only on the side of Dharma as our Bhagavan Shree Krishna was when caught in the generally perceived dilemma of selecting side in the fatricidal war of Kurukshetra? You are a brāhman by birth. You ought to have better civilisational sense as Swami Vivekananda has enjoined upon brāhmans to cultivate and activate thereof both in propagation and in defence of the Dharma. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Mbra Sakib Hasan II : This is the doctrine of Islam that none can be part of Allāh. Please do not confuse Allāh with Īshvar. Every bit of manifestation is a part of Īshvar as per Hindu doctrine. So, the distinction must be made. I hope I am clear on this point.

Sugata Bose @Mbra Sakib Hasan II : You are ignorant, utterly ignorant of Sanatan philosophy. Study Swami Vivekananda and come to reason, sense and sanity about the Sanatan Dharma. Do not superimpose Islam on Sanatan Dharma and try to draw parallels. There is nothing common in conception between the two systems of thought other than what hypersympathetic Hindus try to squeeze in by making enormous accommodation for Islam within the vaster body politic of the Sanatan Dharma to little understanding of unsympathetic converts to the Abrahamic faith largely by the sword of Islam. It is time to revert to the Mother Faith, which is the mother of all religions as Swamiji averred at the Chicago Parliament of Religions on 11 September, 1893. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Parag Kumar Mitra : But Swamiji said so and he must be contextually understood in larger civilisational terms where India will play a seminal role and gradually once again acquire a status that will raise her esteem in the world immeasurably. Hence, the validity of Swamiji's averment which is not to be misconstrued in narrow localised terms, both with reference to realm and realpolitic in current time. The world will venerate India if she spreads out her Sānatan treasures before all and sundry for them to profit by. The Sānatan Dharma propagated effectively, peace shall be in the world. India's good fortune it was to discover the Vedas, to intuitively rationalise on it thereafter to develop the Sanātan shāstras, to hold in her mother's bosom the treasure children of the Vedas, and it is her destiny thereof to carry forth these treasures to the peoples of the wide world who are all inheritors of the Light, being made of the stuff of the pure Spirit which is the substance of the Vedas. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Kaushik Basu : Yes, of course, but these were the three jewel sons of Bhuvaneshvari Devi and Vishvanath Datta who form the purport of the post.

Sugata Bose @Rathin Bhattacharjee : ভট্টাচার্যের উপযুক্ত বক্তব্য |

Sugata Bose @Parag Kumar Mitra : সাহস মানসিক বৃত্তি, নিঃসম্বলেরও থাকে যদি সেই চরিত্র নিয়ে জন্মান অথবা ত্যাগ-তপস্যা-ব্রহ্মচর্য পালন করেন | সাহসই সম্বল |

Sugata Bose @Dhananjoy Chakraborty : These posts themselves are highly educational for souls unaware of the dangers of progressive Islamisation. As a brāhman you should be revelling in reading these posts which are pertinent to protection of the Hindus and preservation of the Dharma. After all the title 'Chakraborty' implies at its deepest the rolling of the Wheel of Dharma which it should be your foremost duty to do. How can you neglect your civilisational calling thus? Even your name Dhananjoy is reminiscent of the valorous third Pāndav who was exhorted by Bhagavān Krishna to eliminate evil instead of cowardly capitulation before the mighty foe which clarion call it seems you are sadly insensitive to hearing. Hence, your present predicament. Arise! Awake! And approaching the wise ones seek the light that will dispel this delusion. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Анандамой Мухопадхяй :  This shall come to pass. When it does, people will see. Right now I have neither time nor opportunity nor quite the inclination to divulge more on this than the stated prophecy. Also, read not superficially the post but read it meticulously and you will understand. Islamic violent aggression has been talked of, not Islam as such.

Sugata Bose @Tanmoy Lodh : Read Vikram Sampath's biography of Veer Savarkar and get to know the great one better. Pride of the Hindus, defender of the Sanatan civilisation, peerless patriot, fighter for freedom who suffered inhuman animal torture in the Cellular Jail of Andamans, awakener of Hindu nationalism which is the future of this country for ages to come, I bow down to this architect of prospective India. 🕉 Hindu!