COMMENTS GALORE ... 76

COMMENTS GALORE ... 76

Sugata Bose @Swami Vibhatmananda : But to enjoy these spiritual delights the Hindus will have to survive as a community. Are you ensuring that by raising resistance to Islamic oppression in Bangladesh and in West Bengal as in other provinces where Muslims have ghettoised themselves and Islamic oppression is running amock? If Hindus survive, then alone can they savour these spiritual sublimities. Raise resistance. Be brave and boldly assert your right to practice of religion without pandering to Islamic intolerance by celebrating Eid-e-Milad-un-Nabi and the like to keep the temperature down. Such an apologetic stance is construed rightly as weakness and not as catholicity of culture by the oppressing adversary. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Satyanand Bhattacharjee : Communist countries and democratic countries like France and the United States of America where the state has by Constitutional provision been kept strictly separate from the Church are truly secular countries. India's secularism is a queer version of its European counterpart, it being deemed here as equal treatment meted out by the government to all religious denominations. For instance, the All India Muslim Personal Law Board can never exist in a truly secular country but it exists here in India. The Waqf Act is another instance of such Indian secularism, whatever the term thereby may mean. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Sanjeev Shrivastava : Let not cowardice unduly bind us into inaction for that is the surest way to destruction en masse at the hands of a historical barbaric force. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Gurudeb O Doya Koro Dino Jone : What advice has President Maharaj given for the persecuted Bangladeshi Hindus so that they may duly defend themselves? 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Satyanand Bhattacharjee : But man is highest only in the spiritual sense. So, to deny God and spirituality degrades man and defeats the very purpose of serving him in the highest enlightened way. Mere materialism degenerates and reduces man to the beast which is what has been the experience of subjects under communist regimes. By rejecting the real focus of the Atman in man, how can real focus on him be achieved? Must not the deepest be the gravitating source and the destination of evolving man? Can foundation be neglected and edifice built? This is tantamount to building castles in the air. Spirituality is the foundation of life and despite its ritualistic trappings must remain the basis for the building of civilisation. The very fact that the Sanatan civilisation has survived for millenia despite the ravages of time is proof of the above averment. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Nilanjana Chakraborty : Perfectly stated. These are people who have ulterior motives in thus continuously maligning the Hindu Dharma and Samāj, and are themselves least spiritual. Remember what Swamiji called them---'heartless intellectuals'. He had exhorted thus: 'Give light to the ignorant; give more light to the learned, for in this age the vanities of learning are much.' To berate the brāhman behoves the one who has a semblance of spiritual altitude, one whose character is spotless and who is endowed with virtues of head and heart that can conveive the sublest principles of the Sanatan Dharma and can empathise with the Hindus en masse, not just sections that are currently convenient. These are self-seeking people who are fundamentally materialists and have not an iota of honesty, or love for their own spiritual tradition of which the brāhman and the kshatriya are the best exemplars. Their only concern is to stir up controversies to gain popular patronage so as to further their commercial interests. These perfidious ones speak of the defects of our societal system that has withstood the shocks of 'scores of shining centuries', to quote Swami Vivekananda, but dare not speak a word against the malpractices among the Muslims and their violent antihuman theology, capitulating in abject cowardice before the apprehended sword of Islam drawn by way of reaction. The reformer should first reform himself before he sets about reforming others. Leave aside these self-seeking individuals who have missed the chance of spiritual progress in this life and by lowly criticism of the Hindus are degrading themselves besides hurting the Sanatan cause by if even a minuscule amount. Better work awaits us, committed defenders of the Dharma, than this wasteful vocation of expending valuable time countering corrosive half-truths dished out by deliberate deceivers. May the Hindus unite in self-defence and a singular solidarity as sung in the Vedic hymn 'संगच्छध्वं संवदध्वं सं वो मनांसि जानताम् '. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Nilanjana Chakraborty : The alarm has been set at 12 a.m. (midnight). Just 5 minutes to it (11.55 p.m.) and ticking fast.

Sugata Bose @Riya Bhattacharya : This sadness must be transformed into effective work for the regeneration of humanity, now being devoured by the agencies of medieval monstrosity. Otherwise such emojis can scarce serve any worthwhile purpose. The jihādis are bold and aggressive. To counter them passive piety or ineffectual effusion will be of no avail. What we need are sturdy individuals of superlative character devoid of the trappings of so-called spiritual virtues that inhibit bold resistance to evil. Such pseudospirituality we have had enough of and need no more, cowards preaching holy truths of the Geeta while cowering before the drawn sword of the irreligious enemy. Preaching and practice must go hand in hand, a la Guru Gobind Singhji in miniature form at least, for each one of us has some power to add on to the cumulative resistive effort and need not remain pretentious soldiers of the Spirit. Swamiji has laid on our shoulders the burden of the defence of the Sanatan Dharma and the Sanatanis. Must we by our cowardice fail him? This is the moot question we need to ponder instead of engaging in futile activities that are debilitating the Hindus day by day. Out of deep thinking the solutions will come and along with them will come the power to execute them in righteous resistance to proliferating evil which so saddens you now. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Prakash Gupta : তরুণ নহি, অস্তগামী অরুণ আমি, সায়াহ্নের অগ্নিশিখা, প্রজ্জ্বলিত প্রবুদ্ধপ্রাণ, ধর্মরক্ষায় নিয়োজিত | 🕉 হিন্দু !

Sugata Bose @Sharmistha Chatterjee : 

পাশুপত সলতে,

এ কথা আর বলতে?

শিবরাত্রির জ্যোতি,

এবার দেখবে কেরামতি |

Sugata Bose @Bolaka Roy : But your rendition is beautiful, improvisation along musically correct lines. Simply beautiful! You are so wonderfully talented, my mist talented disciple.

Sugata Bose @Swami Vibhatmananda : Does manifestation of divinity mean meek submission to religious fanatical violence? Where's the resistance to adharma that ought to adorn the disciples of Krishna? Where is the practicalisation of the message of the Lord in the Geeta? Whither the warrior-spirit, the kshātradharma? Will passive piety lead to spiritual perfection or is such perfection worth it when the community en masse is being massacred, molested and perverted from the Sanatan Dharma by fanatical forces masquerading as adherents of a certain religion? 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Prakash Gupta : Muslims in India want the best of both worlds--Indian penal code in criminal offence and Muslim Personal Law in civil affairs. They are convenient Constitutionalists.

Sugata Bose @Chandan Datta : And character = courage, courage of conviction, courage to defend the Dharma that is under attack from all sides, and courage to defend co-religionists under terrible persecution for 1300 years and more at the hands of Islamic jihādis. 🕉 Hindu! 

Sugata Bose @YouTube [ATN Bangla Talk Show] : Listen to the last few minutes where the real nature of the Islamic agenda that prompted Partition comes through.

https://youtu.be/LMwWZfc7wyE?si=TmWAF7fpeKFz1Hma

Fools contemplating the break-up of India, the ant kicking at the elephant. Bangladesh was formed by breaking India in 1947 and it seems the Islamic design is still on as by scriptural mandate it ought to be. Try anything funny with India and you'll learn your due lesson. The price will be heavy as your parent Pakistan well knows. Ungrateful people united only by fanatical faith that forgets all human attributes when it comes to cultic observance of a malicious kind that is utterly anti-civisational! 

You talk of your right to the Seven Sisters in India's north-east. Shame on you for nursing such lustful thoughts! Remember, your very existence today is because by bloody barbaric violence of 16 August, 1946 (The Great Calcutta Killing) followed by the Noakhali genocide and general terror across the expanse of East Bengal you forced the hands of the Congress to capitulate to your demand for Partition. You talk of the legitimacy of your claim on the north-eastern states of India when your very own legitimacy has never been humanly established, for you forced Partition on religious grounds on us, mutilating your own motherland on both sides. But what of that? To you only the Umma counts and Dar-ul-Harb must at any rate be transformed to Dar-ul-lslam. Is it not? Why the Seven Sisters alone? Does not your Ghazwa-e-Hind agenda lay its claim on the whole of the Indian subcontinent? And then is not the ultimate agenda the subjugation of the whole world to the rule of your totalitarian authority? 

Suhrawardy you talk of as having been removed from his position which prevented your capture of the north-eastern states and even Tripura, that Suhrawardy who was the Great Calcutta Killing's architect and orchestrator, a mass murderer of Bengali Hindus. To you it seems such a genocidal man is hero. That shows your real nature, your malicious motivation, your genocidal intent, now guised as Bangladeshi nationalism. 

You consider Pakistan your ally today, that nation which murdered three million Bengalis, its own citizens in its eastern province, and raped two hundred thousand of your women in their bid to alter permanently your racial characteristic. It is a shame that you could stoop so low! But in point of fact you have not quite, for you people were the ones who sided with the rampaging Khan Senas and helped murder millions of your own men. 

China which has kept fifteen million of your co-religionists, the Uighur Muslims in Xinjiang province, in concentration camps, that country you are now seeking alliance with. Dare you thus declare open enmity with the dragon as you have with your own mother, Punyabhumi Bharatvarsha? Reflect, realise and reform. Else, extinction awaits your evil designs. Vande Mataram! 🕉

Sugata Bose @Satyanand Bhattacharjee : আর শ্বেতশুভ্র ধর্ম যা মানুষের দেবত্বের উদ্বোধন করে ?

Sugata Bose @Chandan Bhattacharjee : You are a singular Bhattacharjee/Bhattacharya brāhman who yet clings to the Sanātan Dharma. Most of the others that I encounter online, barring a few hither and thither, as they necessarily must be, are atheists preaching secularism and harbouring antireligious sentiments. It seems the Bengali brāhmans, devoid of shradhhā, are bent upon self-destruction. It is nice to behold a 'byatikromi Bhattacharjee brāhman' like you, therefore, and I heartily congratulate you for your adherence to your Dharma. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : And it was the first instance of an Islamic republic, I guess, whose failure in consequential terms for the rest of the Islamic nations following the old adage 'Yathā pūrvavat tathā param' (As in the past, so in the future) augurs not too well. 🕉 Hindu !

Sugata Bose @Chandan Bhattacharjee :  But it has to be religion real (yathārtha dharma) and not irreligion (apadharma/adharma) masquerading as such. The problem is that some sort of a 'God'-centred absolutist political movement is also called religion when it is in point of fact a gross misnomer and as such needs to be dealt with in quite the same way as fascism and communism have been dealt with. A totalitarian theology with massive political undercurrent cannot be called religion and must not be accorded the same status as genuine religions like the Bharatiya dharma traditions are. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @YouTube [SR Islamic Media] : China hates Islam and will destroy it if it ever gets Bangladesh in its grip, in much the same way it has destroyed it in Xinjiang where 1.5 crore Uighur Muslims have been brought to book, held in concentration camps, forced to eat pork and made to read from the Communist Party-edited Qur'an. A member of the Chinese Communist Party is made to reside in every Uighur Muslim household to monitor proceedings and every movement of the Muslims is watched via technology and manpower. To turn friendly India into enemy in the hope that opportunistic China will in the bargain be befriended to Bangladesh's help is living in a fool's paradise, for China like USA thinks that she alone is the world and attempts to grab anything that falls into its worldwide web. So, beware Bangladesh lest China finishes off your faith fast! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @YouTube [SR Islamic Media] : Music is harām in Islam and yet ayahs are being musically rendered. What a contradiction Islam as a system is! 

Sugata Bose @Prakash Gupta : আদপে হবে কি ? হওয়ার পথে যে অনেক সমস্যা | এত বৈচিত্র এ দেশে যা ৭৭ বছর ধরে বিভাজনের রাজনীতিতে লালন করা হয়েছে যে আজ হিন্দু রাষ্ট্র করতে গেলেই প্রভূত প্রতিরোধ হবে |

Sugata Bose @Debaprasad Bhattacharya : But good must be done to evil people by resisting the evil perpetrated by them. This is called resistive charity, giving each one what he truly deserves. This is why Sri Krishna exhorted Arjun to fight the evil Kauravas and their comrades-in-arms. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Arvind Kaila : So the Hindus said in the 1930s. The decade 1937-47 proved them wrong.

Sugata Bose @Mainak Bhattacharyya : Sanatan Dharma as philosophy and truth is permanent but not Sanatanis who have shrinking as a percentage of the subcontinental population and whose terrain has been shrinking alike over 1312 years ever since the conquest of Sindh in 712 CE by Muhammad Ibn Qasim. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Rajiv Tyagi : Counter proselytising offensive, that is, reconversion of the erstwhile converted Hindus back to the Sanatan fold. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Satish Mullick : This is not Francois Gautier's writing. This is mine that has been shared by him, albeit perfectly copy-pasted and, in filial adherence to original post thus, authorship acknowledged at the end. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Rajdeep Chatterjee : I wish it were much more, not out of the desire to gain public standing but because these are perilous times and awareness about Islam and its Ghazwa-e-Hind programme is the great need of the hour. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Alain Verdier : Swami Vivekananda had said that the divorce of the Brahmanical brain from the Buddhist heart was the great cause of the downfall of India. This you have also rightly pointed out. We need to rectify this national failing and build a composite civilisation that will be a beautiful blend of head and heart with the hand, the third 'h' of this organic trinity, executing what the brain conceives and the heart feels. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Nidhi Samani : Multifaced man like the multifaced deity God in his anthropomorphic conception is. After all Sugata Bose is a multifaceted man. So, what's the harm in being multifaced? But he certainly is not duplicitous or two-faced in the derogatory sense, as you have implied without proper investigation which in effect proves the shallowness of your perception and in consequence your assertion. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Sanjeev Shrivastava : You and your limitless humour, just a factory of fertile ideas dished out deliciously. Simply inimitable!

Sugata Bose @Shirshendu Dey : Thank you. I was only mentioning the period from the time of the eventual capitulation of Sindh but you have pointed out from your perspective the error in estimation. But I was talking of actual slavery under Islamic rule and not the attacks as such which the Hindu kings successfully repelled. So, you see. 🕉 Hindu!