COMMENTS GALORE ... 115

COMMENTS GALORE ... 115

Sugata Bose @Chandan Bhattacharjee : What one through ignorance had beheld as Matter, now in the light of transcendental Self-experience stands transmuted as the Self itself, the Lord manifest from core to crust as variegated life and light, sentience and insentience rolled into an integrated whole of varying vibration, the symphony of the Soul in its rhythms and rhapsodies, its cascades and courses rendering the rough refined, the fractured whole, the gross glorious and Matter Spirit. Then the thirst for Matter, this trishnā, is quenched forever and Christ's assurance 'Get ye the Kingdom of Heaven and all other things shall be added unto thee' assumes a meaning altogether apart. The vision has changed and with it aspiration. The hunger for Matter, the ravenous appetite of the beast that masquerades as man and despoils brother man, the unquenchable thirst for more and more like fuel to fire added intensifying the flame of forest fertility ever with its gene-driven evolutionary imperatives are nullified forever as the Sun of Knowledge dawns on the human horizon rendering man unto God. And God is pure Spirit. He seeks not Matter, Himself having manifested His Self through Yoga as Matter. Verily, verily has the Rishi equated Matter with Brahman, for the twain have met at last in unitary perception of the essence of things. Now nomenclature hardly matters, call It what you will. The Shāstras call It 'Tat' (pronounced 'Tut'), meaning 'That'. You choose your count. Does it matter anymore? 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Aroup Chatterjee : Read Swami Vivekananda. It will be good for your soul and 'sanskriti'. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Kingshuk Paul : Where did you discover hatred cherished by me if at all hatred is something worth cherishing? I am all love for all irrespective of whether Swamiji or Swamiji's brother was socialist to a degree or communist by declaration and dedication. I am a Vedantist of universal affection, perceiving all as my Self in variegated description and display in multifarious, multitudinous Māyā. 🕉 Hindu!

P.S. Probably you meant 'harbour prejudice and hatred' when you wrote 'cherish prejudice and hatred' if I get you right. Even then I must say that I am prejudiced towards none nor do I harbour hatred towards any. Communists hate non-proletariats though and seek their utter annihilation with repeated instances in history validating their intent. Bhupendranath Datta's fraternal relation with Swamiji cannot alter it. Hence.

Sugata Bose @A Facebook friend : What do you mean? It seems you mistake others' writings to be inspired or copied from yours. Is it? Let it be made very clear that I am creative enough, original in my thinking sufficiently to not require to plagiarise from others as it seems at least that you have implied. Now that is not appreciated by me at all. You have insulted me in the past and I forgave you for that. Now you cast aspersions on me for plagiariaism. Now that is going a bit too far. Such hyper-estimation of your own abilities may to you be warranted but to imagine that I have stooped to such a lowly level as to cheat from you ideas or perspectives, as you put it, is a gross underestimation of my abilities as an original thinker and writer. I hope I have made myself quite clear. Henceforth, think twice before casting casual condemnation on others. My civility need not be misconstrued as inability to defend my position. You are young and talented. So did I feel happy about your gifts and expressed my admiration for them after reading a few of your posts to my literary delight. But it seems that you have entirely misunderstood me right from the beginning with my identity and now with my intent and keep on heaping insults on me. This sort of an allegation has never been made against me because I never borrow from others ideas while writing. I can only tell you that I feel deeply aggrieved, insulted, offended, call It what you will, and will not tolerate such offensive insinuation. 🕉 Hindu! 

P.S. This entire comment of mine was made out of a linguistic misapprehension on my part to this gentleman's ambiguous comment to a post of mine which actually was a bit cheeky on his part but not implying this plagiarism charge on me at all. My strong verbal response here was instigated by a disciple of mine for all her supposed 'wisdom' in interpretation of this ambiguous comment of the supposed offender. It was a faux pas in the end.

Sugata Bose @Tanmaya Pathak : Your own observations are pretty much coarse. The language you often use about cow urine flooding the system of certain individuals is testimony to that irrespective of the fact whether you are an avowed communist or not. You certainly are not civil in your social discourse which was more or less by implication, not on you though, the purport of the post. It seems you are sitting in judgement over others here which is not well received by those upon whom you pass your puerile observations as if with impunity. But now you have received a rejoinder and would be well advised to reform your ways in regard to this casual commenting on others' intent, inclinations and knowledge. Earlier you had caustically asked me as to how I could venture to write on the basis of flimsy knowledge on a subject, yourself assuming omniscience of sorts of course. Each time I ignored you but it seems it is time enough to make you aware that such irreverent remarks are not always well received as ought to become any gentleman of self-respect of sorts. If you are indecent in your use of language, as you have often been thus far, I need not complement you in a like kind in return but surely must make you aware of my annoyance at such misdemeanour on your part. Hope the message has been received well enough for it is loud and clear with no ambiguity whatsoever that could confuse conception except perhaps what minimum decency demands in due delivery. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Tanmaya Pathak : Your assumptions are puerile and bespeak of latent dictatorial tendencies. How do you suppose that I must be at your beck and call to respond in the manner you want me to? I write copiously for diligent observers to read from them my thoughts. If you fail to do so, the fault, dear Brutus, is in you and not in my refusal to respond to your arbitrary demands. 🕉 Hindu!

P.S. Your sickness and tiredness needs treatment from a physician and not a writer like me. Seek your remedy with the right source and health and vigour shall be yours.

Sugata Bose @Tanmaya Pathak : Are you in your senses that you arbitrarily level charges of ignorance and malicious half-truth telling on others? Your peculiar divergences from the purport of a post is amusing but highly unintellectual. Henceforth you deserve no response to your uncivil observations, utterly absurd charges and peculiar data-demands. Bless you! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Biswajit Das : সে তো রেগে গিয়ে বলেন | তা নাহয় বোঝা গেল | কিন্তু জ্ঞানের অহমিকায় যিনি অপরকে মূর্খ আখ্যা দেন, তিনি তো অন্যায় আচরণ করেন | তাঁর অপরকে মূর্খ বলা তো নিজের মূর্খামিরই এক প্রকার পরিচয় দেওয়া |

Sugata Bose @Debaprasad Bhattacharya : Right. But even this use of the word 'right' will irritate the left apart from the fact that I thereby endorse your view. Their vocabulary associates this particular word 'right' with everything that is not right. They are but the 'left' and have rightly been left out of the political discourse in this country as elsewhere in their socialist-communist uniform, uniformly without exception, although like the mutating virus they continue to change colour and operational contour to subvert stable democracies everywhere, aligning with inimical forces while all the while clamouring for human rights and justice, elements of civic life they have ever violated with brutal efficiency in their run regimes across the world for near a century. Sufficient unto the day has been the evil thereof but deluded humanity as yet clings onto this corruption in the hope of utopian salvation here on earth at any cost, literally at any cost, despite displayed humanism and all its ilk in vaunted variegated liberalism, the foggy facade of falsity. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Abir (Meghnad Bose) : যখন ১০ বছর বয়েস (২০০৩), তখন আগ্রা দেখেছিলি | আজ (২০২৬) নাই-আগ্রা (Niagra Falls--New York view) দেখে নিলি | খুব ভাল, খুব ভাল |

Sugata Bose @Swami Shuddhidānanda : Hinduism, if it accepts all religions, does so in so far as they are not anti-human which some religions of wide following and wider persecution of the infidel are. Hence, to make such a generalised statement with no caveat attached makes it a puerile pronouncement opposed to truth.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/19ZZppKpzL/

Sugata Bose @AI : Vedantist Sugata Bose does not mimic Vivekananda or Aurobindo. That is a downright aspersion cast on his original style of writing which may incidentally in places resemble the writing styles of those two seminal writers. An apology is due from AI and a rectification in accordance.

Sugata Bose @Shankar Kumar Chatterjee : An entire book should be written on this 'daughter angle'. It will truly be geomatri, nay, geopitri.

Sugata Bose @Sudipta Sarkar : You should be ashamed of your attitude. You seem to be harbouring a horrendous hatred towards Hinduism. Dare you say the same about Islam openly? Stop speaking of anybody's academic credentials when yours is such pronounced ignorance about the grandeur of this grandest of all religions, the Sanātan Dharma. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Subrata Chatterjee : No, I guess she (Sonia Gandhi) was signalling that she belongs to the Indian National Congress of 'upraised arm' symbol. She must of late be having some identity crisis and being of a generally fearful disposition as has been testified to by Dr. Subramanian Swamy, a friend of her late husband, perhaps out of sheer nervousness that she was culturally-politically being veritably uprooted by the latter stanzas of the 'Vande Mātaram' of pronouncedly Sanātan flavour, she must have panicked and raised an alarm thus, chair having long gone to nationalistic opponents, precipitating this holding crisis thus. In effect she has delightfully shown her Congress credentials. Advertisers ought to learn lessons from this symbolic display of party colours when in dire distress, and so ought her party members to do the same. At any rate, to these pseudosecular political personalities the 'Vande Mātaram' is anathema from title to totality of composition and rendition thereof. But law is law till law is amended, and Gandhi or Maino or any for that matter must observe it. Period. Vande Mātaram! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Avantika Sen : তুমি একেবারে চোখা জবাব দাও সত্যানুভূতির ওপর ভর করে | দমবার পাত্রী নও কোনো মতে | এই spiritটা দারুণ, ক্ষাত্রবীর্য ভাষায় ও ভাবে | লেখোও খুব সুন্দর | চরৈবেতি ! 🕉 হিন্দু !

Sugata Bose @Sudipto Singharoy : Could not follow what you said. Do you mean to say that these are not Tagore's words? Is truth-telling an exercise in political cheapness in your opinion? And what is the Rajya Sabha connection by the way? Have Tagore's words hurt your political predilection and confounded your understanding of communism in a manner that such irrelevant, irreverent remark has been prompted out of you in desperate self-defence as if, as becomes a drowning man in deep sea that clutches at straw to stay afloat?

Sugata Bose @Bruce Hilliger : Please read the write-up full as it stands expanded and rendered more whole now.

Sugata Bose @Suvam Mukherjee : যীশু তো ভারতীয় যোগীদের শিষ্য | সেই যোগসর্বস্য সনাতন ধর্মের মহিমা সমগ্র Christendomএ ছড়িয়ে পড়ুক |

Sugata Bose @Bhaskar Mukherjee : A world-mover may have also had a materialistic background as in the case of Marx. Moreover, the word 'spiritual' is important as it stands in sharp distinction from being politically religious as in the case of Islam, its founder also having been a world-mover. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Kajal Das : Pratul Chandra Gupta's book 'INA in Military Operation (1942--1945) is as yet unpublished and kept classified by GOI.

Sugata Bose @Gopa Sarkar : শতরূপ ঘোষের কাজ নয়, লেনিনকে চাই | আছে নাকি কাছে ?

Sugata Bose @Sudipta Sarkar : Criticise Islam if you are daring enough. Your cowardly aspersions cast regularly on Hinduism makes for humorous reading which you ought to manfully reject as sanity prevails upon your distorted mindset. Hiding behind Ambedkar's photograph does not become a valorous soul nor firing fusillades from behind locked profile, a la online fortress. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Priyadarshi Gupta : 

1. Pratul Chandra Gupta's book 'INA in Military Operation (1942--1945)' possibly points out to British classified data made accessible to the author by Nehru's government that debunks the aircrash theory officially held by the GOI. 

2. It could affect bilateral ties with respect to the concerned states. 

3. It will downplay the contribution of Gandhian non-violent movement towards freeing India from colonial-imperial clutches and shed lustre on Netaji's INA's armed revolutionary struggle that in effect directly and indirectly liberated India.

Sugata Bose @YouTube [zeebangla] : Suman Chattopadhyay's undue interruptions deprived us of much historical reminiscence by this veteran politician (Siddhartha Sankar Ray) hailing on his maternal side from the lineage of the great Chittaranjan Das. When Ray had just begun talking on the Anushilan Samity and P. Dutta, he was made to digress into talking on more recent events which aborted what would otherwise have been invaluable historical reminiscence. This is poor journalism typical of this rather shallow over-talkative journalist.

Sugata Bose @Kaushik Bhattacharjee : That was entirely a Government of India project originally chaired by Ramesh Chandra Majumdar who fell out with the then Education Minister Maulana Abul Kalam Azad whereupon the baton was passed on to Pratul Chandra Gupta. Hence, Gupta was not free to publish on his own the work which was essentially the commission of the GOI.

Sugata Bose @ভাবের খেলার সাথী : ২০২১এর অক্টোবর মাসে দুর্গাপূজোর সময় বাংলাদেশের কুমিল্লা শহরের এক পূজামণ্ডপে রাতের আঁধারে হনুমানজীর পায়ের তলায় এক দুষ্ট জিহাদী নিঃশব্দে কোরান শরীফ রেখে দেয় ও হিন্দুদের ওপর দায় ঠেলে দিয়ে পুলিশে খবর দেয় | এর পর এক সপ্তাহ ধরে গোটা বাংলাদেশ জুড়ে হিন্দুহনন, হিন্দু মন্দির লুন্ঠন, বিগ্রহ ও মন্দির ধ্বংস ও হিন্দু নারী ও বালিকা ধর্ষণ চলে | তখনই এক ঋষিমুখনিঃসৃত ভীষণ অভিসম্পাত বেড়িয়ে আসে যে ৫০ বছর পর ২০৭১ সালের অক্টোবর মাসে এই জিহাদী ধর্ম ধ্বংস হবে | ঋষি বাকসিদ্ধ | তাঁর বাণী অব্যর্থ | এবার মা কালীর দৈববাণী তাঁকে প্রতিহত করেনি | ঘনীভূত পাপরাশির অন্তিম কর্মফল ফলার সময় সমাগত | তাই এই অমানবিক, অসহিষ্ণু, হিংস্র মতবাদের পতনলগ্ন আর ৪৫ বছর পর শিয়রে যমদূতের ন্যায় উপস্থিত হবে যার থেকে তার কোনো রেহাই নেই | অবসান আসন্ন, মাত্র পতনপলের প্রতিক্ষা | 🕉 হিন্দু !

Sugata Bose @Chandan Bhattacharjee :  But fake Gurus galore, gold-seeking godmen, commercial crooks and charlatans would not constitute what you say, 'something is better than nothing'. 

ঠাকুর এও বলতেন, "হেগো গুরু, তার পেদো শিষ্য |" আবার বলতেন, "নিজের অবস্থা বুঝতে পারে না | নিজেও ডোবে, পরকেও ডোবায় |" আবার বলেছেন, "পঞ্চবটিতে গিয়ে দেখি একটা ব্যাঙকে একটা ঢোঁড়ায় ধরেছে | ব্যাংটা চ্যাঁচাচ্ছে | সাপটা ব্যাঙটাকে না পারে গিলতে, না পারে ফেলতে | এতে দুইয়েরই কষ্ট | সাধারণ গুরুরা ওই রকম |" স্বামীজী তাই কুলগুরুপ্রথার ঘোর বিরোধীতা করেছেন |

ঠাকুর প্রায়ই রহস্য করে বলতেন, "আপনি শুতে জাগা পায় না, শঙ্করাকে ডাকে |" এরকম অজস্র কথা আছে ঠাকুরের ভণ্ড, অপরিপক্ক, ঠগ সাধকদের সম্বন্ধে যাঁরা নিজেরা মুক্ত না হয়েই অন্যকে মুক্ত করার ভার নেন ও নিজের তথা শিষ্যশিষ্যার আধ্যাত্মিক সর্বনাশ ডেকে আনেন | 

কঠোপনিষদেও আছে, 

"अविद्यायामन्तरे वर्तमानाः

स्वयं धीराः पण्डितंमन्यमानाः ।

दन्द्रम्यमाणाः परियन्ति मूढा

अन्धेनैव नीयमाना यथान्धाः ॥ ५॥

avidyāyāmantare vartamānāḥ

svayaṃ dhīrāḥ paṇḍitaṃmanyamānāḥ .

dandramyamāṇāḥ pariyanti mūḍhā

andhenaiva nīyamānā yathāndhāḥ .. 5..

Fools dwelling in the dark but misconceiving themselves to be wise and erudite, go round and round by various tortuous paths like the blind led by the blind." 

Katha Upanishad 1.2.5

And here we are talking of nation-level and international-level charlatans, mercenaries masquerading as messiahs. Hence, your argument is misplaced here.

🕉 Hindu!