COMMENTS GALORE ... 87

COMMENTS GALORE ... 87

Sugata Bose @Cheenmoy Saha : স্তাবকের দল সে যুগেও করে নি, এ যুগেও করবে না | নিন্দুকে সে যুগেও করেছে, এ যুগেও করছে | উভয়ই স্বীয় স্বার্থসিদ্ধিতে ব্যস্ত | দেশের কল্যাণের কথা ভাবে কে ? ইতিবাচক সমালোচনা গণতান্ত্রিক প্রক্রিয়ার অবিচ্ছেদ্য অংশ | কিন্তু তা করতে হলে ব্যক্তিকে নীতির থেকে স্বতন্ত্ররূপে দেখতে হবে যা আমাদের দেশে মোটেই হয় না | এ দেশে ব্যক্তিপূজোর বাহুল্য, নীতি-সিদ্ধান্ত-আদর্শের নয় | আর ক্ষুদ্র স্বার্থ চরিতার্থের দুর্দমনীয় স্পৃহা | তাই বিশিষ্ট ব্যক্তির স্তাবককুলকর্তৃক জয়জয়াকার, অপর পক্ষে বিরোধীদের নিম্নরুচির ত্রটিবিচ্যুতি পদে পদে প্রদর্শন | এই তো অবস্থা গণতন্ত্রের, স্বাদেশিকতার, জনমতের | এ হেন পরিস্থিতিতে যেমন গান্ধীজীর, পণ্ডিত নেহরুর সমালোচনা হয়, তেমনই নেতাজী, রবিন্দ্রনাথেরও হওয়ার অবকাশ আছে; ইন্দিরা গান্ধীর সমালোচনা যমন হচ্ছে, মোদীজীরও তেমনই হওয়ার সুযোগ আছে | শুধু এইটুকু স্মরণ রাখা কর্তব্য, সমালোচনা যেন ইতিবাচক ও সভ্য হয়, যেন দলীয় ক্ষুদ্র স্বার্থে দেশের বৃহৎ স্বার্থ খর্ব না হয় |

Sugata Bose @Sanjeev Shrivastava We won't be alive to be pure. The vengeance of Nature is on us.

Sugata Bose @Brototi Pal : Totally, taking the cue from you. You remain in this induced lunacy my principal inducer.

Sugata Bose @Padmanabha Ghosh : I read them on my own. So do you. Why depend upon others? Why complain when one has not done one's own reading in an age when their works are so easily available in purchased hard copy and in free soft copy?

Sugata Bose @Gemma Smith : They have a poor idea of God, a la Arab warlord egging his men on in Arab expansionism, all other adjustments to social living being made to facilitate the grand project. Woman's womb they found out early was their main source of warrior men and to this end they directed all their efforts in inhibiting women, curtailing their freedom and reducing them to breeding machines of little other value in life.

Sugata Bose @Jahsim Islam : Awakening will lead to resistance and ouster of the invasive influences from the body politic of the nation, desert doctrines that have desecrated our motherland, destroyed our civilisation and partitioned the country. Awakening will lead to strength and galvanisation of the positive civilisational forces for the rolling of the Wheel of Dharma with accelerated motion. Awakening will lead to weeding of the perfidious forces that are tending with gradual demographic change and with traitorous political backing to Islamise the nation in the not-so-distant future. Awakening is the national imperative for the civilisational blueprint of our sages and saints, Rishis and Avatars to unfold in executed action for the future flourishing of humanity. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Imtiaz Mahmood : Perhaps, the resolution of historical forces has a hidden deeper movement that guides humanity along obscure evolutionary paths. The withdrawal of Britain from the subcontinent unleashed vast forces that violently resolved themselves in the net product of Partition. India was relieved of the vilest segment of its erstwhile polity which facilitated its phenomenal growth. But the growing Islamisation of provincial pockets thereafter does not augur well for the integral health of the country, West Bengal, Assam and Kerala leading the way of this invasive infection. It is, in the words of Dr. Bill Warner, a gravitational slow precipitation over sufficient time that cannot be averted once the tipping point of 25% of the population has been reached by the minority Muslims in any polity. Now, in West Bengal it is way past it. What in your estimation and analysis is your inference about the future of these states and what are your suggestions regarding its redress? 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Prasiddha VaraPrasad : But without total resolution of the issue, for the same problems are resurfacing with demographic shift and perfidious political patronage of a laughably large 'minority'. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Jha Rakesh : The solution lies in bolstering the Ex-Muslim Movement and opening the doors to reconversion to the Sanatan Dharma. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Prasiddha VaraPrasad : Unofficially 34% (Muslim population in West Bengal) and growing by the day. Situation alarming! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Debaprasad Bhattacharya : Post fiery passages from 'The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda'. These are too passive and will not ignite the minds of the youth sufficiently as is the need of the hour. Post from 'Lectures from Colombo to Almora' where quaking stuff is in abundance.

Sugata Bose @Deep w4 : (Modi) Facing upto Putin in a friendly karate sparring.

Sugata Bose @Palki Sharma : You are too loud, Palki Sharma, almost arrogantly so. Greater musicality would suit a news reader that would jar the ear less and soothe it more without in any way diminishing the truth-content of the news item read or the vigour of articulation involved. Optimisation is the key. Have you not heard of Shakespeare's 'brevity is the soul of wit'? Well, in its extended import it would mean that the golden mean is the soul of all expression, even all manifestation, so to say, barring the faintest bit of disequibrium necessarily involved, for a lost balance of cosmic forces is the impeller of the universal movement forwards and backwards in alternately reversing cyclical order. So may we countenance that fair bit of musical mean and only traces of discordant dispersion that will preserve articulate beauty in news-reading and not mar it with jarring display of hyper-affirmation of personality in an otherwise impersonal exercise. 🕉

Sugata Bose @Mohsin Anayat Raja : Kashmir is not a nation but is a Union Territory of India. Get your facts correct first. Despite your false propaganda of no avail, Kashmir historically has been and will remain an integral part of India. Even POJK belongs to India and will be integrated into the vast body of the motherland. At a near or a not so near date even Pakistan and Bangladesh which were artificially created by murderous goons of the All India Muslim League with political backing of the British, will be reintegrated into the mother body of Sanatan Bharatvarsha which will have then regained its original territorial and civilisational status. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Mohsin Anayat Raja : Kashmir is not a nation but is a Union Territory of India. Get your facts correct first. Despite your false propaganda of no avail, Kashmir historically has been and will remain an integral part of India. Even POJK belongs to India and will be integrated into the vast body of the motherland. At a near or a not so near date even Pakistan and Bangladesh which were artificially created by murderous goons of the All India Muslim League with political backing of the British, will be reintegrated into the mother body of Sanatan Bharatvarsha which will have then regained its original territorial and civilisational status. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Abdul Rehman Malik : And Pakistan should hand over Pakistan itself to India as it was created by Husseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy, the Butcher of Bengal, inspired by his Machiavellian master, the Qayamat-e-Quaid-e-Azam, whose combined atrocities on the Hindus have become the benchmark of barbarism in the subcontinent. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Muhammad Arsalan Qureshi : Hand over Pakistan to us.

Sugata Bose @Muhammed Shayan : We need Pakistan itself to render whole our dismembered geography and this is no joke nor any circus in the offing.

Sugata Bose @Chaudhry Ramiz Riaz : When Pakistan has been reduced to rubble you will understand what Jahannum-e-Jahan is.

Sugata Bose @NOman Khattak : Hand over Pakistan, Astrapachār Akhanda Bharat will be over.

Sugata Bose @Ab Rouf Maitlo : We cannot (hand over Yogiji) because the ISI under yogic influence will then become spiritual and will win the Nobel Prize for Peace instead of the Ghazwa-e-Hind Prize for War. Its sudden transformation and consequent failure to wage war against the kafir-mushrik Hindu will then render it munafiq and damn it into Dozakh, a destiny we cannot help induce in the Inter Services Intelligence of Pakistan despite all its bungling of brain. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Farooq Khalid : It is time to hand over Pakistan itself to India.

Sugata Bose @Tanveer Ahmed Khattak : Hand over Pakistan to India and things will be over. After all, where was your Pakistan before Partition? Carved out of India you dare to say these things?

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : Alas, few will! And those that will, will make sure that they do not acknowledge reading it. You are an exception to this rule who being an exception all the more prove the rule.

Sugata Bose @Sutanu Chatterjee : There you go. Launched it again, the root missile. [Reference to Sutanu's mentioning in his comment that General (now Field Marshal) Asim Munir as having his roots in all probability in the divine Bharatiya ancestry of muni/rishi.]

Sugata Bose @Kanu Debroy : Right you are, very right. But necessity is one thing and greed another, especially if Thakur's own monastic order violates such spiritual stipulation of its Avatar-founder. The Order is giving in to the third dreaded human vice, greed, as its economic activities by way of raising funds in various ways which are not quite in keeping with its own erstwhile lofty tradition are concerned. 

"The bane of a spiritual order is when it hangs on to the sleeves of the rich," says Swami Vivekananda. So you see. Rome has witnessed the spiritual downfall of the Christian Church, Bharatvarsha has seen the downfall of the Buddhist Order, and the first clear signs of spiritual decay and material ascendancy are being perceived by the discerning eye in the Ramakrishna Order. Whether devotees should resist it or facilitate the decline is upto them. Myself have long chosen the path of sounding the bell. Of course, this decline has decades back started when the Mission chose to legally de-Hinduise itself before being brought back to sanity by the three member Supreme Court bench in 1995. 

You see, Mahamaya weaves her deception net imperceptibly and the chess players aren't aware of the wrong moves they are making but the bystander, if he is knowledgeable in the game, can point them out. (Ref: Thakur's parable to the effect) But men innocent of the nuances of the game can only cheer on the erring player to his checkmated end. 

Reams can I write on this but will you have the patience or openness of mind to lend me your eyes? (Ref: Mark Anthony's speech in 'Julius Caesar') Hence, I conclude this not-so-brief observation. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : Nehru wrote 'Glimpses of World History' where he gave us glimpses. Here he gives us a glimpse of the origin of the All India Muslim League. Hence, he gives us a hint of its date of birth. He is testing us, his nephews and nieces, and also giving us a hint as to the potential intellectual capacity of his progeny and great progeny in the making in the womb of futurity whose evidence we are to our daily delight witnessing now. This is a perfect demonstration of Nehruvian honest submission of history, deflected only by years five, much like the deflection of the left ear from the right ear by the width of the face intermediate. Therein lies historical distortion, deliberate and not so deliberate, of the Nehruvian era where deflection of years merely represents an honest endeavour in dishonesty. Now, you are correcting such historical heresies, my friend. How unthinking of you! How utterly uncharitable such utterance! 🕉 Satyam Jnānam Anantam Brahma! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : Does a dead man live again except in rebirth in another incarnation? So must the Mission be resurrected in a new Mission set up by a new Avatār in keeping with Sri Ramakrishna's prophecy of his prospective reincarnation.

Sugata Bose @Kanu Debroy : Even the Mission has lost its spiritual bearings and is running after money. That is what I mean to stress on.

Sugata Bose @Debaprasad Bhattacharya : Swamiji has been bedecked in artistically effeminate colour unlike as in the original photograph. His facial expression has also been tampered with to render it more feminine which is a travesty of truth. This is the despicable state of decadent devotion these days of growing effeminacy which he abhorred. You must take care to preserve Swamiji's manliness in appearance as well as in the original rendering of his optical image, for that would be in keeping with truth. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Shankar Kumar Chatterjee : I know this characteristic to be common in our current culturally consumed community. We have had so many revolutionaries in our close and extended family but have had only one such in the army. Cowardice has assumed its pseudonym in culture even as culture has plummeted to its nadir. Now we are neither hither nor thither. I keep thundering away against all inequities but receive scant response by way of readership. Write soft superficial stuff and you have gallants galore following you. Touch a raw nerve in the body of established institutions or individuals and you have to dine alone in the desert, deserted by all the bhadraloks who would dance instead round rosy illusions and dainty delusions reinforced daily by their dope-delivering mentors of soaring speeches and lost morality. The kshatriya spirit is well nigh gone and it is lazy rumination in the past that defines Bengal today. Even unto the day is the evil thereof. We must turn on a new leaf. You have already been up the branch there while most of us have not even approximated the garden where flowers die to live in fruition that the orchard thereof may flourish and afforest as yet infertile fields that this vast human concourse in its variegated distribution seems to be. 🕉

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : Lovely epithet ascribed to me. I wholeheartedly accept it, eventhough most, perhaps, would scant allow me such privilege of principled holding.

Sugata Bose @Priyadarshi Gupta : You haven't quite read the intent and content of the post. It relates to the current scenario, the abysmally low representation of Bengalis in the Armed Forces today and for some decades past. There is no Bengal Regiment in the Army, mark it. As for the part relating to devotion to Bapu, well, that is by way of pure sarcasm to highlight the fundamental point of the, should I say, aversion of the Bengalis from joining the Armed Forces.

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : Commercial cultural corrosion.

Sugata Bose @Thakurdas Shrestha : Kashmir has been bleeding since late 14th century when the first wave of Hindu persecution by Muslims began which culminated in the first exodus of the Hindus from the valley in 1405. Thereafter, six more Hindu exoduses have happened with the seventh and the last one till date occurring in 1990. Once a totally Hindu-Buddhist habitat, Kashmir is now 98% Muslim by habitation consequent on continuous persecution of Kashmiri Hindus by the Muslims there. But whether Hindu, Buddhist or Muslim by affiliation to faith, Kashmir was, is and will remain an integral part of India. The expelled Pandits will have to be rehabilitated there and with the reconversion process taking root and the reverting to the Mother fold of erstwhile Sanatanis who had historically been perverted from the faith, Kashmir will regain its former glory as the cultural hub of ancient and pre-Mohammedan medieval India. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Ram Singh : You may think that the comment is insensitive but if you reflect you will find that there is a germ of truth in it. Not all are equipped linguistically to speak in sophisticated terms while attempting to communicate an idea but we ought to take the positive intent of the language used and not its apparently insensitive implication merely while pronouncing our judgement thereon. A comprehensive view of the comment would make it intelligible while being up in arms on a partisan or even human basis would render understanding sterile. However, the observation of the gentleman would have been better off if limited merely to men and not extended to the fairer sex of gentler attributes as well who lived on to witness the horrific crimes perpetrated on their husbands. Labelling them as being devoid of courage is distasteful doubtlessly and cannot be condoned. But compulsory military training imarted to all and sundry of a suitable age would make a marked difference in the scheme of things in future and needs to be seriously considered. 🕉 Hindu!