COMMENTS GALORE ... 82

COMMENTS GALORE ... 82

Sugata Bose @Bilwadal Tapadar : কি পরিবর্তন করেছেন তিনি তো দেখতেই পাচ্ছি | দিনে দিনে রসাতলে যাচ্ছে রাজ্য | অধর্মের চাটুকারিতা করা আমার কর্ম নয়, ধর্ম তো নয়ই | অতএব, ওই যে বললাম, বুদ্ধিতে শান দিন, তবেই আমার বক্তব্য বুঝবেন |

Sugata Bose @Shankar Kumar Chatterjee : If Cardus and cricket can be, why not Mozart and cricket?

Sugata Bose @Bilwadal Tapadar : পরিবর্তন হবে নিয়তির অমোঘ বিধানে | তা আমার অপেক্ষা রাখে না | কর্মফল পেতেই হবে |

Sugata Bose @Bilwadal Tapadar : অনশন ছিল না ভোজনের অন্বেষণ ছিল, ভাববার বিষয় |

Sugata Bose @Imtiaz Mahmood : Israel is more powerful than the invoked agency of Erdogan. Hence, his prayer, plea, petition will all go unanswered as the said agency will have exhausted resources to muster strength enough to even defend his diminishing domain, much less destroy the mighty infidel enemy of persistent refusal to submit to his inferior power.

Sugata Bose @Ram Guna : It sure will. But the workings of karma are complex and often imperceptible even as they are seemingly inscrutable.

Sugata Bose @George Adebisi : Despicable doubtlessly but not senile. He is deliberate in his designs, a shrewd politician who is threatening to overturn Mustafa Kemal Pasha's progressive means and take Turkey back inevitably to the days of the Caliphate with its regressive returns.

Sugata Bose @Debaprasad Bhattacharya : You and I, if we support each other, then others will follow. This is the secret of organisation. It grows over time if the ideal be kept intact and activated in daily life. All movements begin with a seminal one of singular power whose following forge bonds in due course that integrate society. So must we keep making sect after sect harmoniously within the general body of Hinduism that will keep the body politic vibrant and strong enough to resist invasive influences while expanding their influence worldwide. All is not lost. In fact nothing is lost if we stick to what Swamiji said, and act accordingly. But it must not be the cherrypicked version of the Ramakrishna Mission but must be our own understanding of Swamiji's virile message of Hindu self-defence and expansion. 🕉

Sugata Bose @Suvam Mukherjee : Why are you shedding tears? Rise in defence of the Dharma.

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : Perfect assessment, except for the half sainthood. I do not regard him as a saint at all. To me he was a seminal thinker, intellectual and writer. As regards his revolutionary track-record, the less said the better. The Alipore Bomb Case saw the valiant deaths of two bravehearts, Kanailal Datta and Satyendranath Basu, in their successful bid to save Aurobindo from definite death by the noose. But the succeeding cowardly capitulation before the British authorities by way of submission of revolutionary plans has remained one of the worst blots on the revolutionary movement for freedom. Abdication of leadership trust and responsibility at a critical juncture has cast a perennial blot on Ghosh's career which can never be erased.

Sugata Bose @Fb friend: আমার মত হিন্দুও আছেন যাঁরা লড়তে জানেন, কোনো কারণেই দুর্বল রোদনের বশবর্তী হননা, যাঁরা নেতিবাচক, হতাশাব্যঞ্জক বক্তব্য পেশ করেই ক্ষান্ত হননা, স্বধর্মরক্ষাকল্পে শক্তিমান অবস্থান গ্রহণ করেন সর্বতোভাবে | এই সংখ্যা যত বাড়বে---এবং তা বাড়বেই যুগধর্মানুসারে---ততই সমস্যা সমাধানের দিকে যাবে ও সনাতন সভ্যতা সংরক্ষিত হবে | 🕉 হিন্দু !

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : She (Britain) does and is reaping what she has sown worldwide. But the fallout of it (Islamisation of Britain) could be catastrophic for the world as well which would not be in sync with its overall progression. Hindus are in for a worse global predicament.

Sugata Bose @Parnika Bubna : You have a strange concept of mathematical extension where two minutes equates to a day. And it is not merely a concept. It is idea practised to perfection, albeit often making allowance for further extension beyond the stipulated time of passage of the night and the day.

Sugata Bose @James Afreek : The moon cracked from side to side.

Sugata Bose @Kapil Patil : Do you know that 'you' is both singular and plural. Or, are you innocent of grammar? If this rejoinder is difficult to understand and seems nonsensical as well, take the help of another 'you' to make sense of it. Moreover, the literary element and philosophical conception both seem beyond you that you have made such a heavy weather of my observation in the post proper.

Sugata Bose @Kapil Patil : Study Swami Vivekananda in the original English. Keep reading my posts religiously. Read 'Voice of India' publications, especially Sita Ram Goel.

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh: The sannyasi is beyond all worldly duties but performs beneficial acts constantly in a dispassionate manner to integrate society and bring it closer to God. Lokasangrahārtham. 🕉

Sugata Bose @Readers of All-time Test Match World XI post : I have largely gone for modern players, considering the modern game to be of a higher level than the earlier version and performers easier to judge on account of my personal experience of watching them in action either on field from the spectator's gallery or on television, something which I have not been privy to with regard to the ancients. Hence the choice.

Sugata Bose @Swapan Kumar Ghosh : We are old. Our digestive system has weakened. The liberal youth are happily buying into these deliberate falsities through their youthful gullibility and emotional expansiveness which give fillip to these dastardly movements designed to destroy the heritage and culture of this timeless civilisation of ours. 🕉

Sugata Bose @Goutam Biswas : No, you must have the courage to name her (Mamata Banerjee). Otherwise it will be deemed cowardice.

Sugata Bose @Chandan Bhattacharjee : Ramakrishna Mission cannot directly involve themselves in politics as they are mandated to abstain from it totally by Swamiji. However, they can easily maintain a stricter spiritual code regarding politicians and not pander to their vanities in any sense as over some years past they have been wont to doing. This means the monks in positions of power are no more spiritual enough to delight in God and not seek earthly benefits from the public and politicians which make them so subservient. 

Materialism has affected the Mission and it is no more the order of exalted spirituality as of yore. Work has become attachment which necessarily seeks pecuniary power and in the process perverts the pristine principles of the peerless Paramahamsa and his equally peerless protégé. 'Back to Ramakrishna' must now become the clarion call for the Mission even as Nityaswarupanandaji in the 1980s had sounded it as 'Back to Vivekananda' in his bid to set the Mission right but had to himself face isolation in consequence. 

Spiritual people of such eminence, as the high-positioned monks of the Mission are, ought to have the sagacity to set the morals of the masses right by themselves leading exemplary lives and making the Mission adhere to the pristine principles of the Master. If they themselves err in this regard, it is idle to imagine that the Mission can be of any significant use to society at large beyond rendering such doubtlessly seminal services as imparting education to children and young adults, medical services to people, distress relief and soft spiritual preaching of sorts, and last but not the least, building a series of Ramakrishna temples across the country at a time when the country is otherwise going to ruin on account of a terrible loss of morals consequent on gluttony comsuming it to which the Mission of late has fallen a victim too, unfortunately. The question arises though whether the Yugāvatār, that Sri Ramakrishna doubtlessly is, descends on earth to make temples, render flood relief, build medical centres etc. while vice proliferates and virtue continues to subside, with his followers remaining blissfully indifferent to it, or whether he descends to root out evil and supplant it with virtue above all, never remaining aloof to the horrors the Hindus have been facing for a millennium and more of which the fanatically fuelled Partition of the motherland has been the climactic development with its gory never-ending aftermath continuing to destroy Hindu hopes of survival as a civilisation. These and much more trouble the mind but the Mission and its multitude of followers seem to be blissfully apathetic to these concerns that consume my midnight oil, and in consequence the Ramakrishna Mission has become an organisation in isolated insignificance so far as Hindu revival is concerned. To top it all, it had shamelessly appealed for non-Hindu minority status to combat malicious Marxist interference in its workings during the Left Front's rule, a fate fatal which it was spared, courtesy the Supreme Court of India in 1995. If the Left Front Government forced its hands to seek non-Hindu minority status, what would the Nazi Government have induced in it, one remains to wonder! 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Abhisekhar Majumdar : 

You are absolutely right. 

Not enough to fight 

But to well win the bout 

And roguish enemy rout.

Sugata Bose @Devanjan Sarkar : Sindh was under Islamic occupation since 712 CE. The earliest Islamic incursions which did damage to pockets of north-western India took place within years of their founder's death. Repeated forays by Ghazni from 1001 CE to 1027 CE inflicted heavy human casualty, estimated at around two million, on India. Earlier Afghanistan, the erstwhile Gandhār, had been conquered by Islamic forces. So, it is not accurate to say that it was with the fall of Prithviraj Chauhan in 1192 CE that Islamic reign began in India with its horrific consequences. India in those days must be understood to be the entire subcontinent compromising today's Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, Nepal, Sikkim, Burma (Brahmadesh/Myanmar) and Sri Lanka. Hence, we must not limit Islamic domination only to today's political India, partitioned in 1947. It has been a sporadic and continuous oppression by adherents of this desert cult for almost 1400 years, right since the mid-730s CE. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Prakash Gupta : Savarkar's solution, amended and adjusted, is perhaps the way.

Sugata Bose @Susanta Mullick : Third class performance devoid of aesthetic sense. Inharmonious hyper-paced dance movements not in rhythm with the song at all. Effeminacy that has come to afflict our benighted Hindu race that is going to spell its doom. 🕉

Sugata Bose @Whatsapp reader : Do not irritate readers with your rising 'love' signs on my public Whatsapp messages. It makes reading difficult. You are ruining reading time as the rising emojis distract attention, obstruct vision and allow for lesser opportunity to finish reading before the next message darts in.

Sugata Bose @Sangeeta Ghosh : What about Sri Aurobindo's calling Netaji a traitor? Have you read that as well? Was that labelling from the lips (read, pen) of a Rishi quite Rishilike?

Sugata Bose @Sangeeta Ghosh : Hang on. You'll be supplied with all authentic documents in substantiation of my assertion. Already posted on above. Read it. More to follow.

Sugata Bose @Sangeeta Ghosh Have a look at these documents furnished above by way of authentication of my earlier averment. Do you want proof about his puerile claims from his published works from Pondicherry Ashrama? They are legion where he makes fantastic claims about himself and passes caustic comments about many a stalwart including Ramakrishna and Vivekananda. He claims to have been the action at a distance for Hitler's downfall for which the demonic forces inflicted on him his leg injury. Rishilike? Please be diligent in your reading before attempting to counter me. If you are sincere, you will spend time reading and discovering facts rather than asking me for each and every document which I will painstakingly gather for you only to see you bypassing them and blissfully entertaining earlier make-believe ideas. Neither is Aurobindo Rishi nor Subhas Chandra but they were both seminal beings of significance in respective realms, the former in literature and the latter in politics. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Santosh Kumar Banerjee : Not at all. Criticism ought to be the spice of democratic disposition as opposed to the imperial legacy which you seem to bear which prompts you to hold intelligence hostage to hijacking by faith. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Tanmoy Bandopadhyay : We should always criticise, fairly and rationally with facts and findings, as I do and have here done. I could have cited more but deem Facebook readers to be too casual to even cast a cursory glance through such furnishings. Hence the imposed indulgence in indolence thereof. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Ujjal Kumar Ghosh : You are an honest person who does not hypocritically hold intelligence hostage to hijacking by faith or by hearsay but cares to delve deep into relevant literature to uncover the buried body now dancing the lane of lies as its skeletal sibling in supposed truth. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Santosh Kumar Banerjee : Limit? What limit? And my 'gyan'? Who is to measure that? You? Are you privy to it, the inner workings of the cosmic mind manifest in individual whirlpools of personality? Where's the beginning and where's the end, my friend? What limit shall you impose on the limitless one? And age? Citizen? What age is of the soul that has traversed a million lives? What citizenry binds the cosmic man who has sundered the bonds that fetter the finite man? Chew on these, dear divine, till the light dawns. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Tanmoy Bandopadhyay : Sri Aurobindo was egotism personified----quite evident from his latter-day observations on premier personalities like Ramakrishna, Vivekananda, Gandhi and Bose---and he was patently against the blossoming Bose's bearings, having failed to elicit godlike reverence for his self from the redoubtable revolutionary whose attitude, aspiration and achievements with respect to the freedom struggle stood in sharp contrast to his owned failed credentials in that regard. Aurobindo's stupendous unverified spiritual claims regarding his changing the course of the Second World War and much more about the evolution of man are far more than plain egotism. They are preposterous claims having no basis in facts or findings nor in sense or sanity. Of course, his blind adherents will forthwith posit that his achievements were supersensory and supersane at that, and, hence, not to be rationalised in any manner other than the Aurobindo way, much like the blue light perceived in meditation by a devotee was quickly dubbed 'the Aurobindo Light', heaven knows why, by the doubt-dissolving divine. Vivekananda, however, held that faith ought to pass the test of reason and critical scrutiny. Such arbitrary assertion of the Supramental Descent altering the course of organic evolution on earth is fair bit of intellectual jugglery for sure but is a weakening irrational proposition that betrays the spiritual hollowness of its propounder. 🕉 Hindu!

Sugata Bose @Imtiaz Mahmood : You are extremely innovative. Sorry to understate thus. But it's true. Your wit, your intelligence, your caustic commenting, your perceptive presentation, all make you a marvel of a man, again begging your forgiveness for the unintended understatement.

Sugata Bose @Atif Abdul Qayyum : Abbassi Are you from that Palestine which was there when the state of Israel was not there?

Sugata Bose @Sangeeta Ghosh : You may entertain whatever notions you please about me. That is your prerogative. Mine is to highlight my thoughts, my cogitations, conclusions, assessments and analyses for kindred souls and myself to read and clarify conceptions. An immature polity regards due criticism as disrespect. A mature citizenry differs in this respect. That is the beauty of democratic free speech, unfortunately under increasing curbs these days of sinking culture. If Aurobindo has the right to criticise Subhas Chandra and the latter has the right to counter-criticise him, a right which rightfully both have, so do I have the right to measure their statements in my mind and give articulation to my inferences thereof. Criticising Gandhi and Nehru has become staple to Bose's followers but they cannot bear a bit of criticism of Bose which is a psychological feature of weak fanatical minds. It seems some of Aurobindo's ardent fans are no less in this regard but choose not to read passages cited for their consumption in response to their pleas in protest to furnish proofs for statements made about the thinker of Pondicherry. Well, facts are there but fans fare better off without them, harbouring rosy notions about society's settled seers while committing themselves to altered perceptions about people who dare dispose dust from shelves that lie in neglect and discover dishonorable features from files thereof regarding seminal souls that have trodden the soil of this blessed motherland of ours. 🕉 Hindu!